Tuesday 1 May 2012

Breaking away is hard to do

I've been having a couple of low-ish days, not surprisingly, considering my unemployment status and the feeling that great prospects are not in sight at the moment. Apart from something I have just applied for the other day, there is nothing else that feels right for me and I'm not feeling positive about sending out any spec cover letters with CV to places that are not advertising. That initiative takes a lot of time and emotional energy - time, I have, emotional energy, not so much of that at the moment. Maybe the endless days of rain we are having in the UK this month haven't helped my mood. Please let there be a dry and full sunny day soon!

One of the things that also seems to have prompted some funny feelings is that yesterday a couple of my academic contacts got in touch with me via facebook and invited me to join their friends list. These are very nice people indeed, and I really enjoyed meeting them at conferences, talking to them about their very interesting work, having a laugh, and feeling like I was accepted as part of the academic community in my field. They are still at it, and going strong. One contact is a highly respectable name in the field, is younger than me (well I am almost 49, so maybe that's not too surprising!), and publishes prolifically. He is the kind of academic who makes you question how he manages it all - how many hours of sleep does he survive on and who's cooking his meals, doing the food shopping and laundry. Answer - it must be someone else because he doesn't seem to stop for a minute and is always key speaking at important conferences, symposiums, etc. I do seem to remember reading in the acknowledgements of one of his books, his thank you to his partner who supplied him with constant food for fuel, and I imagine, the tender loving care he must have needed to finish the thing. Oh, isn't he lucky, I thought at the time. Still, I do find it hard to not to like him. He's a lovely (young) man [Oh dear, I am now beginning to sound like my mother...].

The other contact is a younger, more recent female PhD finisher, not long behind me. But unlike me, she has managed to crack on with an impressive, growing list of publications after PhD and Research Assistant job, and I'm sure, she should have a permanent post by now, or very soon. I first met her online when she contacted me to tell me how impressed she was by a paper I had published. It was amazing to hear so much praise, but with it, she continued to tell me about all of her research and publication plans, asking what I was up to, what would I be publishing next, and so on. This all came at the time when I was half considering leaving but I couldn't quite confess this to her after all of her compliments! I managed to bump up the paper I was presenting at the time and some of the hopes around that.

So now, I am invited as a facebook friend to these successful, keen (and young - oh, did I say that already?) UK academics in my field, and I'm feeling a strange kind of anxiety around this. I have accepted their invites and have looked at their posts and see lots of chat around fun at conferences, references to this work and that, to this academic and that other one. My discomforts are around coming out as a leaver - finally - to these people, and feeling as though I may come up as the subject of the failed academic if the opportunity arises in chat in the future. What other way will they be able to understand my decision. I guess she wasn't invested enough. Yes, she was good, but actually, she wasn't that good. You've got to stick with this for a long time to reap rewards (i.e., a decent, paid job!). I wonder what she's going to do now? Oh, you know what they say about failed academics...they work in publishing. (Yes, I have heard this joke tossed around between academics.)

Since these facebook invites I have looked around their facebooks, admiring the pics, noticing familiar faces, people I've met at symposiums and other events. I see their list of friends and comments made by many other academics in the field with whom they are chummy. I've read these people's admirable work, and as I'm the one peering like a voyeur into these lives, or little, short moments within them, I feel like the interloper who has no right to be there. This is difficult because I feel like I've broken up from a sort of intimate 'relationship' with this community, yet I am still trying to remain 'friends'. There are some romantic relationships that break up and seem to be able, at some point later, become 'good friends' as they find common ground together. At a basic level I do see these people as kind, warm human beings - their research interests fully embrace the realm of feelings, yet I can't escape the feeling that coming out as abandoning ship, will prompt the usual responses. Is there anything I can do for you? Can I read your stuff and offer feedback? How about taking on some teaching here? What about speaking at our department seminar on that work you were doing? All nice, supportive stuff, but I've gone past that now.

Facebook communications take a bit of careful identity management, I guess. Perhaps this is a good opportunity to just be open about where I am and why, if asked, without going into too many other details about it. It will be interesting to see if I remain on their friends list.

8 comments:

  1. Oy. I left at much the same career point as you did (after getting the PhD and finishing a 4-year Oxbridge JRF), and much as I like my erstwhile academic colleagues, I maintain almost no contact. I simply don't want to see myself through their eyes. Perhaps someday I'll be strong enough to enjoy their company without seeing myself as they see me, and perhaps someday more than one or two of them will see me as simply a career changer rather than a failed academic, but it's just not at this point yet.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know what you mean about needing the time to build up the strength 'to enjoy their company without seeing myself as they see me'. This is the most difficult thing, I think. I do have closer academic friends who have been very understanding, however, I must say, even they persisted at the start to offer 'support' via academic means - saying I had such potential, how about taking on this bit of teaching so you can explore this research area of yours, you should really keep on writing.... I think they have finally grasped that these suggestions have just made my decision making much harder and that making a total career move can be a positive thing.

      Delete
  2. Oh, do I completely understand how you feel. Since I'm still in Grad School City and still run into people from time to time, I'm Facebook friends with quite a few former academic colleagues. Most of my closest friends from academia have gone onto jobs in other cities or states by now, but the acquaintances remain there on my Facebook.

    It's a constant struggle with me - when to "come out" to my acquaintances as an academic leaver. How to describe the transition without making them feel bad for me or crack jokes about how I'm secretly miserable or "couldn't cut it." How much information I should give to my really good friends so that they'll believe that I'm happy and will stop asking me when I'm going to start applying for "real" (read: academic) jobs again.

    The amount of worry and impression management you have to do with this transition is surprising, isn't it? But yes, even when I'm a year out and solidly into a new job, I'm still finding that it's hard to manage.

    (P.S. I'm so glad your son is doing better and is back to normal!!)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. JC, I think you're very right in your point about 'How to describe the transition...' This had made me reflect on my conversations with closer academic friends (mentioned in my reply to Caitlin) perhaps in the earlier days of decision-making and worry around it. Those moments felt confusing and highly emotional, maybe inviting the usual responses in which they felt they could try to help me get through a rough academic patch that might such blow over. Now that I'm more sure about leaving, my delivery can be more confident, hopefully!

      And thanks so much for your kind words around my son. What a time that was! Now, we are just left with the
      usual teenage dilemmas, which is more than enough.

      Delete
  3. My hearth goes to you! At first I thought... She should be honest with them, but I guess it doesn't matter, right? Because at the end of the day, you are being honest with yourself, and that's the most important thing. <3

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Anonymous. Yes, honesty is good overall, I think, but gauging it in a way that feels manageable.

      Delete
  4. I'm sorry to hear about your low days. I've been having quite a few myself. My upcoming posts are about to take a "maudlin" turn, I fear...but such is life. I try to be authentic about the good days and the ones where I'm sobbing while making a meatloaf for dinner. :)

    I know that I've pulled back A LOT from academic friends/colleagues. In part because I no longer felt we had as much in common, but also because I've found that these people don't have as much interest in me now that I'm not talking about work 24/7. And, at the end of the day, while I do worry a fair amount about what they might think about my leaving, I also know that they aren't the ones who have to live my life and deal with my set of circumstances. I also know that some of that "she didn't try hard enough" BS is to cover up their own insecurities, fears, and unhappiness in their own situations.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Currer, I think you've made a good point about these contacts just losing interest as the point conversation between you, by default, has to move away from the total academic world of work and subject focus. Eventually, I will stop being 'invited' as a contact person/friend, by these people, because I simply won't offer them any interesting communications. I think there are some useful comparisons we might make here with the experience that many people must feel when they retire in their older age from professions which defined much of their whole identities. This reminds me how important it is to have other interests outside of work/career.

      Delete